3 private links
https://contemporarythinkers.org/allan-bloom/
https://archive.org/details/allan-blooms-interpretive-essay-platos-republic-1 - audio
Bloom doesn't treat it as simply negative, but he doesn't treat it as simply good either. His view is closer to ambivalent:
Source of philosophy: The refusal to be content with the conventional is what drives someone to ask what is good by nature, so it's essential.
Source of danger: That same restlessness, without wisdom, is what makes tyrants. Bloom reads Glaucon as an erotic, ambitious nature who could go either way, and much of the dialogue is Socrates trying to turn that longing toward philosophy.
Source of tension with the city: Most people's contentment is what holds a city together, so philosophers are unsettling to it. Bloom sees this as a permanent political problem, not something to be solved.
Bloom clearly admires the philosophic life, but he's candid that it's costly and potentially destabilizing.
Guter Artikel
At the core of the myth of the machine, he argued, is the idea that the development of technology is inherently connected to the improvement of the human condition. In other words, if we just keep upgrading our tech, human life will keep getting better.
The myth of the machine offers a secular equivalent. It allows us to view beneficial outcomes as inherent to technological development itself, while understanding harms as incidental or as unintended byproducts. These downsides are often seen as the result of human failures, whether through misuse by bad actors or through careless deployment.
According to Mumford, a similar transvaluation took place in the modern era when we ceased to value technology in the service of human goals and values and came instead to regard the efficiency and productivity obtained through technical innovation as an end in itself, to which humans should subordinate themselves.
https://sts.hks.harvard.edu/people/fellows/conor-mcglynn/
https://www.tcd.ie/alumni/alumni/interviews/conor-mcglynn.php